Style Selections Vinyl Plank

Transform Your Space with Budget-Friendly Luxury That Lasts

Have you ever walked into a room with gorgeous hardwood floors and immediately felt that warm, inviting ambiance? There’s something about beautiful flooring that transforms a space from ordinary to extraordinary. But then reality hits—the maintenance, the susceptibility to water damage, and oh, that price tag! This is where Style Selections vinyl plank flooring enters the picture, offering an elegant solution that doesn’t require a second mortgage.

My journey with vinyl plank flooring began three years ago when a washing machine leak destroyed my kitchen hardwood. Devastated and on a tight budget, I discovered Style Selections vinyl plank at Lowe’s, and it changed everything. Now, I’m sharing everything I’ve learned about this remarkable budget-friendly flooring option that delivers premium aesthetics without the premium price tag.

What Exactly Is Style Selections Vinyl Plank Flooring?

Style Selections is Lowe’s exclusive house brand of vinyl plank flooring, designed to offer consumers high-quality flooring solutions at competitive prices. But what exactly are you getting when you purchase these planks?

At its core, Style Selections vinyl plank is a multi-layer flooring product. The construction typically includes:

1. A wear layer on top that protects against scratches, stains, and daily wear
2. A decorative layer featuring high-definition printing technology that replicates wood grain patterns
3. A rigid or flexible core layer providing stability and durability
4. A backing layer that adds additional support and sometimes includes attached underlayment

These layers work together to create planks that not only look remarkably like hardwood but also offer practical benefits that natural wood simply cannot match. The technology behind modern vinyl plank flooring has advanced tremendously in recent years, allowing manufacturers to create products that can genuinely fool the eye—and even sometimes the touch.

Style Selections offers various lines within their vinyl plank collection, including options with different thicknesses, installation methods, and finish styles. Their products range from value-oriented offerings to more premium selections with enhanced features.

What sets Style Selections apart from many competitors is their commitment to providing reasonable quality at accessible price points. While they may not offer the absolute top-tier specifications found in luxury vinyl plank brands, they’ve carved out a valuable niche in the “good value for money” category that appeals to homeowners and DIYers working within practical budgets.

Waterproof Warriors: Can Style Selections Handle Moisture?

One of the most significant advantages of vinyl plank flooring—and a reason many homeowners choose it over traditional hardwood—is its water resistance capabilities. But are all Style Selections vinyl planks genuinely waterproof?

The short answer is: mostly yes, but with some nuance.

Style Selections offers two main categories of vinyl plank flooring:

1. 100% waterproof rigid core vinyl plank – These premium options feature a solid waterproof core (often SPC or WPC) that won’t swell, buckle, or warp when exposed to moisture. These planks are suitable for bathrooms, kitchens, basements, and other moisture-prone areas.
2. Water-resistant flexible vinyl plank – Some more budget-friendly Style Selections options offer excellent water resistance but may not be completely impervious to prolonged water exposure. These are ideal for moderate-moisture areas.

I installed the waterproof rigid core version in my bathroom two years ago, and despite daily showers, occasional splashes, and my son’s impressive ability to create small floods while brushing his teeth, the flooring remains pristine. The planks have maintained their shape and appearance without any signs of water damage.

It’s important to note that while the planks themselves may be waterproof, water can still potentially seep between planks and reach your subfloor if not properly sealed at the perimeter. For areas with frequent water exposure, I recommend:

• Using 100% silicone caulk around the perimeter of bathrooms and other wet areas
• Wiping up standing water promptly (even waterproof materials benefit from basic care)
• Ensuring proper installation with tight seams between planks

The waterproof nature of Style Selections vinyl plank makes it particularly versatile across various rooms in your home. Unlike hardwood, which requires careful moisture management, or laminate, which can swell when wet, properly installed waterproof vinyl plank gives you peace of mind during everyday spills and accidents.

Installation Made Simple: A DIYer’s Dream

One of the most appealing aspects of Style Selections vinyl plank flooring is its DIY-friendly installation. As someone who installed it myself with zero previous flooring experience, I can attest that it’s genuinely accessible to beginners with basic tools and a willingness to learn.

Style Selections offers two primary installation methods:

Click-Lock (Floating) Installation

Most of their vinyl plank products feature an interlocking edge system that allows planks to “click” together without adhesives. This floating floor installation is:

• Fast and straightforward for DIYers
• Requires minimal specialized tools
• Creates no mess from adhesives
• Allows for easy removal if needed in the future
• Can be walked on immediately after installation

The click-lock system creates tight seams between planks while allowing for natural expansion and contraction with temperature changes. For my living room renovation, I completed about 300 square feet over a weekend using this method, saving thousands in installation costs.

Peel-and-Stick Installation

Some Style Selections products come with self-adhesive backing for direct application to prepared subfloors. This method:

• Works well for smaller spaces
• Requires careful subfloor preparation
• Creates a more permanent installation
• May be easier for complex cutting patterns

Before installation, proper preparation is crucial. Here’s a simplified process based on my experience:

1. Acclimation: Allow your flooring to sit in the installation room for 48 hours to adjust to temperature and humidity
2. Subfloor preparation: Ensure your subfloor is clean, dry, and level (within 3/16″ over 10 feet)
3. Underlayment: Unless your product has attached padding, install appropriate underlayment
4. Planning: Lay out your installation pattern, staggering end joints by at least 6 inches
5. Installation: Begin in a corner and work systematically across the room
6. Trim work: Install quarter round or baseboards to cover expansion gaps

The most challenging aspects for beginners are typically cutting planks to fit around doorways, cabinets, and other obstacles. A jigsaw or table saw makes these cuts manageable, though a simple utility knife can work for straight cuts in thinner planks.

What I appreciated most during my installation was the forgiving nature of vinyl plank. Made a mistake? Simply disconnect the planks and try again—something impossible with traditional tile or hardwood installations.

Where to Find Style Selections: Shopping Smart

As Lowe’s house brand, Style Selections vinyl plank flooring is exclusively available at Lowe’s home improvement stores and through their website. This exclusivity has pros and cons worth considering.

In-Store Advantages

Shopping for flooring in person at Lowe’s offers several benefits:

• You can physically see and touch samples
• Staff can answer questions directly
• Immediate availability for many products
• Potential for negotiation on larger orders
• Easy returns if needed

I found the in-store experience particularly valuable when comparing different styles. The lighting in your home can dramatically affect how flooring looks, so I recommend:

• Taking samples home before making final decisions
• Viewing samples at different times of day in your actual space
• Comparing against your existing furniture and decor

Online Shopping Considerations

Purchasing through Lowe’s website provides convenience but requires more research:

• Read customer reviews carefully
• Order samples before committing to large quantities
• Check delivery timeframes and costs
• Look for online-only promotions

During my bathroom renovation, I found that some specialty colors were only available online or required special ordering through the store. Planning ahead is essential if you’re working with specific timelines.

One shopping strategy I’ve found effective is to visit the store initially to narrow down options, then monitor the Lowe’s website for sales on your preferred choices. Flooring frequently goes on promotion, and timing your purchase can result in significant savings.

It’s worth noting that while Style Selections is exclusive to Lowe’s, the actual manufacturing is typically done by larger flooring companies that produce similar products under different brand names for other retailers. This means you might find comparable options elsewhere if a particular Style Selections product is out of stock.

Weighing the Pros and Cons: Is Style Selections Right for You?

Every flooring option comes with advantages and limitations. After installing Style Selections in multiple rooms and living with it daily, here’s my honest assessment:

The Pros

1. Affordability: Style Selections typically costs 30-50% less than premium vinyl brands while delivering solid performance.
2. Waterproof options: Their waterproof lines provide peace of mind in moisture-prone areas.
3. Realistic appearance: High-definition printing creates authentic wood-look patterns that can be surprisingly convincing.
4. DIY-friendly installation: The click-lock system is genuinely accessible to beginners.
5. Durability in high-traffic areas: The wear layer stands up well to daily foot traffic, especially in living spaces and hallways.
6. Low maintenance: Simple cleaning with a damp mop and mild cleaner is all that’s typically required.
7. Comfort underfoot: Vinyl plank is warmer and softer than ceramic tile or natural stone.
8. Wide style selection: From traditional oak to contemporary gray-washed finishes, the aesthetic options are extensive.

The Cons

1. Variable quality between lines: Some budget options have thinner wear layers that may show wear more quickly.
2. Not environmentally friendly: As a PVC product, vinyl plank isn’t biodegradable or easily recyclable.
3. Can dent under heavy furniture: Without proper protection, heavy items can leave permanent impressions.
4. Limited repair options: Damaged planks in the middle of a room can be challenging to replace.
5. Potential for fading in direct sunlight: Extended UV exposure can cause color changes over time.
6. Limited refinishing options: Unlike hardwood, vinyl plank cannot be sanded and refinished.
7. Possible VOC emissions: Some vinyl products may off-gas volatile organic compounds initially.

In my experience, the advantages significantly outweigh the disadvantages for most residential applications. The key is understanding the limitations and selecting the appropriate product line for your specific needs and budget.

Durability Deep Dive: How Long Will It Last?

When investing in flooring, longevity is a primary concern. How does Style Selections stack up in the durability department?

The lifespan of Style Selections vinyl plank flooring varies significantly based on several factors:

1. Wear layer thickness: This is perhaps the most important durability indicator. Style Selections offers products with wear layers ranging from 6 mil (budget) to 20 mil (premium). For reference:
   • 6-8 mil: Suitable for light residential use
   • 12 mil: Good for general residential use
   • 20 mil: Appropriate for heavy residential and light commercial applications
2. Core construction: Rigid core products generally offer better dent resistance than flexible vinyl.
3. Installation quality: Properly installed flooring with well-prepared subfloors lasts longer.
4. Maintenance routine: Regular cleaning and proper care extend lifespan considerably.
5. Environmental factors: Sun exposure, humidity fluctuations, and temperature extremes can impact longevity.

In my home, the Style Selections 12 mil wear layer product in our living room has endured three years of family life—including a large dog, a cat, and countless gatherings—with minimal visible wear. The planks in high-traffic pathways show slight surface dulling when viewed at certain angles, but no major scratches or damage.

For areas like kitchens and entryways, I highly recommend selecting options with at least a 12 mil wear layer. The extra investment pays off over time in better scratch and scuff resistance.

One durability concern specific to click-lock vinyl is seam integrity. Quality products with well-engineered locking systems maintain tight connections over time, while budget options may develop gaps. So far, my Style Selections installations have maintained solid seams without separation.

Compared to other flooring types, moderately-priced Style Selections vinyl plank typically offers:

• Similar or better water resistance than laminate
• Better scratch resistance than many engineered hardwoods
• More dent resistance than softer solid hardwoods like pine
• Less durability than porcelain tile (but more comfort underfoot)

With proper installation and care, quality Style Selections vinyl plank with a 12-20 mil wear layer can reasonably be expected to perform well for 10-20 years in residential settings before significant wear becomes apparent.

Bathroom-Ready: A Perfect Match for Wet Spaces

Bathrooms present unique challenges for flooring—constant humidity, water splashes, temperature fluctuations, and cleaning chemicals. Can Style Selections vinyl plank handle these demands?

In my experience, Style Selections waterproof vinyl plank is an excellent bathroom flooring solution, offering significant advantages over traditional options like ceramic tile or sheet vinyl.

The waterproof core construction means the planks won’t swell or deteriorate when exposed to moisture—a critical feature in bathroom environments. Unlike laminate or hardwood, which can warp when wet, properly installed waterproof vinyl maintains its structural integrity even in steamy conditions.

Beyond moisture resistance, other bathroom-specific benefits include:

1. Comfort underfoot: Vinyl plank is noticeably warmer than ceramic tile on cold mornings.
2. Slip resistance: Many Style Selections options include textured surfaces that provide better traction when wet compared to polished surfaces.
3. Easier installation: For DIYers, vinyl plank is significantly simpler to install than ceramic tile, with no mortar, grout, or specialized tools required.
4. Softer impact surface: Dropped items are less likely to break on vinyl than on ceramic tile.

For maximum bathroom performance, I recommend:

• Selecting Style Selections products specifically labeled as 100% waterproof
• Applying silicone caulk around the perimeter and at toilet flanges
• Using manufacturers’ recommended waterproof underlayment if specified
• Ensuring tight seams between planks during installation

My bathroom installation has weathered two years of daily showers, occasional overflows, and regular cleaning without any signs of water damage or seam separation. The only maintenance requirement has been regular cleaning and occasional checks of the silicone seals.

One consideration for bathrooms is proper ventilation. Even waterproof flooring performs better in environments where humidity levels are controlled. A functioning exhaust fan helps maintain ideal conditions for your flooring and prevents other moisture-related issues.

Budget Breakdown: What Will It Cost You?

Cost considerations are often the driving factor in flooring decisions. Style Selections positions itself as a value brand, but what exactly can you expect to pay?

Style Selections vinyl plank flooring typically ranges from $1.50 to $3.50 per square foot for the materials alone, depending on:

1. Product line and features: Waterproof rigid core products command higher prices than basic flexible vinyl.
2. Wear layer thickness: Products with thicker, more durable wear layers cost more.
3. Attached underlayment: Some products include integrated padding at a premium.
4. Visual features: More complex embossing and realistic wood grain patterns may increase pricing.

Beyond the flooring itself, additional costs may include:

• Underlayment (if not attached): $0.30-$0.75 per square foot
• Vapor barrier (for concrete subfloors): $0.15-$0.30 per square foot
• Transition pieces and trim: $10-$30 per piece
• Tools (if not already owned): $50-$200
• Professional installation (if not DIY): $2-$4 per square foot

For my 300-square-foot living room, the total material cost was approximately $900 using a mid-range Style Selections product with attached underlayment. By installing it myself, I saved roughly $900 in labor costs compared to professional installation quotes.

When budgeting, I recommend purchasing approximately 10% more flooring than your measured square footage to account for cuts, waste, and potential future repairs. It’s also wise to keep a few extra boxes for future repairs, as exact color matches may be difficult to find years later if a plank needs replacement.

Compared to other flooring options, Style Selections typically offers significant savings:

• 30-50% less expensive than premium vinyl brands like COREtec or Shaw
• 50-70% less expensive than mid-range hardwood flooring
• Comparable to or slightly more than basic laminate flooring
• More expensive than economy sheet vinyl but with better aesthetics and durability

The value proposition becomes clearer when considering the total lifecycle cost—while premium options may last longer, the initial savings with Style Selections allows for eventual replacement while still potentially saving money over more expensive alternatives.

Colors and Styles: Finding Your Perfect Match

One of Style Selections’ greatest strengths is the breadth of aesthetic options available. Whether your taste runs traditional, contemporary, rustic, or somewhere in between, there’s likely a style that complements your vision.

The Style Selections vinyl plank collection includes:

Wood-Look Options

• Traditional oak tones: Warm honey, medium brown, and golden finishes
• Gray-washed woods: Contemporary cool-toned options in light to dark gray
• Rustic finishes: Distressed and weathered looks with textured surfaces
• Exotic wood impressions: Styles mimicking walnut, cherry, and mahogany
• Blonde woods: Light natural finishes reminiscent of maple and birch

Plank Widths and Lengths

• Narrow traditional: 3-4 inch widths for classic appearances
• Medium width: 5-6 inch planks for versatile styling
• Wide plank: 7+ inch widths for contemporary, spacious looks
• Mixed width: Some collections feature varied widths for custom appearances
• Long planks: Extended lengths (up to 48 inches) for fewer seams and more authentic wood look

Surface Textures

• Smooth: Subtle grain patterns with minimal texture
• Embossed in register (EIR): Texture aligned with the visual wood grain pattern
• Hand-scraped look: Dimensional texture mimicking artisan-finished hardwood
• Wire-brushed appearance: Light texture showing wood grain characteristics
• Distressed: Pronounced texture with “worn” edges and surfaces

What impressed me during selection was how the various textures interact with light. In my dining room, the embossed-in-register Style Selections planks create subtle shadow patterns when sunlight streams through the windows, enhancing the natural wood illusion.

When selecting colors, consider:

1. Room size: Lighter colors generally make spaces feel larger, while darker tones create intimacy.
2. Light conditions: Natural light levels dramatically affect how flooring colors appear.
3. Existing elements: Coordinate with permanent features like cabinets and countertops.
4. Cleaning visibility: Lighter colors show dust more readily; darker colors show scratches more obviously.
5. Design longevity: Extremely trendy colors may date more quickly than classic wood tones.

I recommend taking sample planks home and viewing them in your actual space at different times of day before making a final decision. What looks perfect under store lighting may appear dramatically different in your home’s natural light.

Reality Check: Does It Really Look Like Wood?

Let’s address the elephant in the room: can vinyl plank genuinely replicate the appearance of natural hardwood? The answer is both yes and no, with some important nuances.

Modern vinyl plank technology has made tremendous advances in realistic appearance through:

1. High-definition printing: Detailed wood grain patterns captured from real hardwood
2. Embossed textures: Physical surface variations that align with visual grain patterns
3. Color variation: Subtle tonal differences within and between planks
4. Matte finishes: Less artificial sheen than older vinyl products
5. Realistic sizing: Authentic plank dimensions similar to natural wood

Style Selections incorporates these technologies to varying degrees across their product lines. Their premium options achieve remarkably convincing wood looks, while budget lines may appear more obviously synthetic.

In my experience, guests often initially mistake our living room Style Selections flooring for engineered hardwood. It’s only upon closer inspection or physical contact that the vinyl nature becomes apparent. The most common giveaways are:

• Uniform temperature (wood feels cooler to the touch)
• Subtle hollow sound when walked on (compared to solid wood’s density)
• Perfect consistency in certain patterns (nature is more random)
• Extremely uniform plank dimensions (real wood has more variation)

From a standing height of 5-6 feet away, quality Style Selections vinyl plank creates a very convincing wood illusion. The realism is enhanced by:

• Using products with varied plank appearances (avoiding repetitive patterns)
• Proper installation with staggered end joints
• Appropriate transition pieces at room boundaries
• Complementary wall colors and furniture

For absolute realism, natural hardwood remains unmatched—but comes with significantly higher costs and maintenance requirements. The aesthetic compromise with quality vinyl plank is minor compared to the practical benefits for many homeowners.

It’s worth noting that Style Selections’ wood authenticity varies by price point. Their premium lines with enhanced embossing and color variation achieve much more convincing results than basic options. If realistic appearance is your primary concern, investing in their higher-end products generally yields noticeably better results.

Warranty Wisdom: Protection for Your Investment

Understanding the warranty coverage for your flooring provides important insights into the manufacturer’s confidence in their product and your protection as a consumer. Style Selections vinyl plank flooring typically comes with tiered warranty protection based on the specific product line.

Most Style Selections vinyl plank products include:

1. Residential wear warranty: Generally ranging from 15-30 years depending on the product line, this covers wear-through of the decorative layer under normal residential use.
2. Structural warranty: Often lifetime coverage against manufacturing defects like delamination or core failure when properly installed and maintained.
3. Waterproof warranty: For products labeled waterproof, coverage against damage from normal household spills and moisture when properly installed.

These warranties sound comprehensive, but it’s essential to understand the typical limitations:

• Installation must follow manufacturer specifications exactly
• Proof of purchase and professional installation records may be required
• Coverage is often prorated based on years since purchase
• Normal wear and tear, including scratches and scuffs, is generally excluded
• Damage from improper maintenance is not covered
• Replacement typically covers materials only, not labor costs

In my experience, the most valuable aspect of the warranty is protection against manufacturing defects that appear early in the product’s life. If planks begin separating, edges curl, or the wear layer prematurely fails within the first few years, the warranty provides important recourse.

To maximize warranty protection:

1. Save your original purchase receipt and product information
2. Take photos during installation showing proper techniques
3. Follow all maintenance guidelines precisely
4. Document any issues immediately when they appear

Should you need to file a warranty claim, the process typically begins at the Lowe’s store where you purchased the flooring. Having complete documentation significantly improves your chances of a successful claim.

While warranties provide some peace of mind, I’ve found that selecting a quality product with appropriate specifications for your space is far more important than warranty duration. A 30-year warranty on a thin-wear-layer product placed in a high-traffic environment won’t prevent premature wear.

Keeping It Beautiful: Cleaning and Maintenance

One of vinyl plank’s most appealing features is its simple maintenance requirements compared to natural hardwood. With proper care, Style Selections vinyl plank flooring maintains its appearance with minimal effort.

Routine Cleaning

For daily and weekly maintenance:

1. Sweep or vacuum regularly: Use a soft-bristle broom or vacuum with a hard floor setting (avoid beater bars that may scratch).
2. Damp mopping: Clean with a microfiber mop slightly dampened with warm water and a pH-neutral cleaner specifically formulated for vinyl flooring.
3. Spot cleaning: Address spills promptly by blotting (not rubbing) with a clean cloth.

I’ve found that a simple weekly routine of vacuuming followed by damp mopping keeps our Style Selections floors looking fresh. For the cleaning solution, I use:

• 1 gallon of warm water
• ¼ cup of white vinegar
• A few drops of dish soap

This gentle mixture removes everyday dirt without leaving residue that can dull the finish.

Preventative Maintenance

To extend your flooring’s lifespan:

1. Use furniture pads: Place felt protectors under furniture legs to prevent scratches and dents.
2. Entryway mats: Place doormats at entrances to capture dirt and moisture before they reach your flooring.
3. Control humidity: Maintain indoor relative humidity between 35-55% to prevent excessive expansion and contraction.
4. Avoid direct sunlight: Use window treatments to prevent prolonged UV exposure that can fade vinyl over time.
5. Proper cleaning tools: Skip harsh chemicals, steam mops, and abrasive scrubbers that can damage the wear layer.

After three years with Style Selections vinyl plank, I’ve found that consistent basic care has been sufficient to maintain its appearance. The flooring in our home has retained its color and finish with no special treatments beyond the routine cleaning described above.

What to Avoid

Several common practices can damage vinyl plank flooring:

• Steam cleaning (excessive heat can break down adhesives)
• Wax-based cleaners (create dull buildup)
• Abrasive cleaners or tools (scratch the wear layer)
• Excessive water (can seep between planks)
• Sliding heavy furniture (causes scratches and tears)
• Rubber-backed mats (may cause discoloration)

By following these simple maintenance guidelines, Style Selections vinyl plank flooring should maintain its appearance for many years with minimal effort—a significant advantage over more demanding flooring materials.

DIY Installation: Can Beginners Really Do It?

As someone who installed Style Selections vinyl plank with zero prior flooring experience, I can confidently say that this flooring is genuinely beginner-friendly for DIY installation. However, success depends on preparation, patience, and understanding a few key principles.

What Makes It DIY-Friendly?

Several factors contribute to the accessibility of vinyl plank installation:

1. Click-lock system: The interlocking edges create secure connections without adhesives or specialized tools.
2. Cutting simplicity: Vinyl plank can be cut with a utility knife, though a jigsaw or miter saw makes the job easier.
3. Forgiving nature: Made a mistake? Simply disconnect the planks and try again.
4. Minimal special tools: Basic household tools handle most installation needs.
5. No curing time: The floor is immediately usable after installation.

For my first installation, I found the learning curve relatively gentle. The first few rows took the most time as I learned the technique, but speed improved dramatically as I progressed.

Basic Tools You’ll Need

A starter installation kit includes:

• Tape measure and straight edge
• Utility knife with spare blades
• Tapping block (often included with flooring)
• Pull bar for tight spaces
• Rubber mallet
• Spacers for expansion gaps
• Knee pads (your joints will thank you)

For more efficiency, consider:

• Jigsaw or table saw for faster, cleaner cuts
• Miter saw for precise angle cuts
• Jamb saw for undercutting door frames

Common Beginner Challenges

Several aspects of installation can trip up first-timers:

1. Subfloor preparation: Taking time to ensure your subfloor is clean, dry, and level is crucial for long-term success.
2. Working around obstacles: Cutting around door jambs, cabinetry, and irregular shapes requires careful measurement and patience.
3. Maintaining proper expansion gaps: Vinyl plank needs space around the perimeter to expand and contract with temperature changes.
4. Staggering end joints: Ensuring end seams are offset by at least 6 inches between rows creates structural stability and visual appeal.

My biggest challenge was cutting planks to fit around door frames and heating vents. I found that making paper templates first helped achieve precise cuts without wasting material.

For beginners considering their first installation, I recommend:

• Starting with a smaller, simpler room to build confidence
• Watching multiple installation videos specifically for your product
• Reading the manufacturer’s instructions completely before beginning
• Having extra material (about 10% more than measured) for mistakes
• Working methodically rather than rushing

With careful preparation and a willingness to learn as you go, most homeowners with basic DIY skills can successfully install Style Selections vinyl plank flooring. The satisfaction of completing the project yourself adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your new floors.

Scratch Repair: Fixing the Inevitable

Even with the most careful household, scratches eventually happen. The good news is that Style Selections vinyl plank offers several repair options depending on the severity of the damage.

For Light Surface Scratches

Minor scratches that only affect the wear layer’s surface can often be remedied with:

1. Vinyl floor polish: Products like Rejuvenate or Weiman Vinyl Floor Polish can fill in light scratches and restore shine.
2. Scratch repair kits: Manufacturer-approved repair pens color-match the scratch to make it less visible.
3. Buff and polish: For very light scratches, a soft cloth and vinyl-specific polish may reduce visibility.

I’ve successfully addressed several minor scratches in our dining room using a combination of cleaning and applying vinyl floor polish. The scratches haven’t disappeared completely, but they’re significantly less noticeable, especially under normal lighting.

For Deep Scratches and Gouges

More substantial damage that penetrates through the wear layer requires different approaches:

1. Vinyl putty: Color-matched filler compounds designed specifically for vinyl flooring can repair deeper scratches and small gouges.
2. Heat treatment: Some professional repair services use controlled heat to partially melt and reform damaged vinyl.
3. Plank replacement: For severe damage, replacing the affected plank may be necessary.

When our dog’s nail gouged a deep scratch near our patio door, I successfully used a vinyl repair kit with putty filler. The repair isn’t perfect—visible under close inspection—but blends well enough to be unnoticeable during normal use.

Plank Replacement Process

If a plank is severely damaged, replacement is the best option:

1. Identify the damaged plank and verify you have matching replacement material
2. Use a circular saw or utility knife to cut through the center of the damaged plank
3. Carefully remove the damaged pieces without harming surrounding planks
4. Clean the exposed subfloor area
5. Prepare the replacement plank by removing the bottom portion of the locking mechanism
6. Apply a thin bead of vinyl flooring adhesive to the exposed subfloor
7. Slide the replacement plank into position
8. Wipe away any excess adhesive and place weight on the repair until dry

This process works best for planks in the middle of a room, though it requires care and patience. I haven’t personally needed to replace an entire plank yet, but have assisted a friend with this process on their Style Selections flooring with good results.

The key to living with vinyl plank is understanding that some wear is inevitable over time. Perfect maintenance is impossible in real-world conditions with families, pets, and daily life. The goal is managing damage to maintain overall appearance, which Style Selections vinyl plank generally allows through these various repair options.

Installing Over Existing Floors: What Works?

One of vinyl plank’s most practical advantages is its ability to be installed over many existing flooring types—potentially saving significant time, money, and disruption during renovations. But can Style Selections vinyl plank really go over your existing tile, hardwood, or laminate?

The answer depends on several factors:

Installing Over Ceramic or Porcelain Tile

Style Selections vinyl plank can be installed over existing tile if:

• The tile is securely bonded to the subfloor without loose pieces
• Grout lines are less than ¼ inch wide and 1/8 inch deep
• The surface is level (or can be leveled with appropriate compound)
• The floor height allows for additional flooring thickness

For my kitchen renovation, I successfully installed Style Selections over existing ceramic tile after:

1. Thoroughly cleaning the tile surface
2. Filling deeper grout lines with leveling compound
3. Addressing any lippage (height differences between tiles)
4. Using a quality underlayment designed for hard surfaces

The result was excellent, with no telegraphing of the tile pattern through the vinyl and a completely stable walking surface.

Installing Over Hardwood or Laminate

Existing wood flooring can serve as a base for vinyl plank when:

• The wood is solidly attached without squeaks or movement
• The surface is flat and level within 3/16″ over 10 feet
• Any damaged areas are repaired or replaced
• Appropriate underlayment is used if required

In my home office, I installed Style Selections over an older engineered hardwood floor that had some surface wear but was structurally sound. The installation went smoothly, though I needed to address a few uneven areas with sanding before proceeding.

Challenging Substrates

Some existing flooring types present special challenges:

1. Cushioned vinyl flooring: Generally needs to be removed as it’s too soft for proper support
2. Carpet: Must be completely removed, including pad and staples
3. Multiple layers of flooring: May create excessive height issues and potential instability
4. Radiant heat systems: Requires specific Style Selections products rated for this application

The primary considerations for any overlay installation are:

• Floor height: Will the added thickness create problems at transitions or with door clearances?
• Subfloor condition: Is the existing floor solid, level, and free of moisture issues?
• Manufacturer guidelines: Does Style Selections specifically approve installation over your existing floor type?

When in doubt, removing the existing flooring down to the subfloor provides the most reliable foundation. However, the overlay approach can work exceptionally well when conditions are suitable, saving considerable time and effort.

My overlay installations have performed identically to those installed on fresh subfloors, with no additional issues over several years of use. The key is honest assessment of the existing floor’s condition rather than hoping to hide problems under new flooring.

Thickness Matters: Understanding Vinyl Plank Specifications

When evaluating Style Selections vinyl plank options, thickness specifications significantly impact performance, feel, and longevity. But the numbers can be confusing—what exactly do those measurements mean?

Style Selections offers vinyl plank products in various thickness ranges:

Overall Thickness

The total plank thickness typically ranges from 2mm to 8mm (approximately 1/12″ to 5/16″). This measurement includes all layers of the plank. Generally:

• 2-3mm: Economy options, suitable for light residential use
• 4-5mm: Standard residential thickness for general use
• 6-8mm: Premium options for high-traffic areas and improved comfort

The overall thickness affects:

1. Sound absorption: Thicker planks generally create less noise when walked upon
2. Temperature insulation: Thicker products provide better thermal barrier properties
3. Comfort underfoot: More substantial planks typically feel more solid and comfortable
4. Subfloor imperfection hiding: Thicker products can better mask minor subfloor irregularities

In my home, I used 5mm Style Selections planks in bedrooms and 7mm planks in high-traffic areas like the living room. The difference in foot feel is subtle but noticeable, with the thicker product feeling more substantial underfoot.

Wear Layer Thickness

Perhaps more important than overall thickness is the wear layer—the clear protective top layer that guards against scratches, stains, and wear. Style Selections offers:

• 6 mil: Basic protection for light-use areas
• 12 mil: Standard protection for normal household traffic
• 20 mil: Enhanced protection for high-traffic residential or light commercial use

For context, a mil is 1/1000 of an inch, so a 12 mil wear layer is 0.012 inches thick. While this seems minute, the difference between a 6 mil and 20 mil wear layer is substantial in real-world durability.

My experience suggests that 12 mil is the sweet spot for most residential applications, offering good wear resistance without the premium price of thicker options. In our high-traffic hallway, 12 mil Style Selections planks have maintained their appearance with only minimal signs of wear after three years.

Core Construction

Style Selections offers both:

1. Flexible vinyl plank: Traditional construction that bends easily
2. Rigid core vinyl plank: Includes SPC (Stone Plastic Composite) or WPC (Wood Plastic Composite) cores that provide enhanced stability and dent resistance

Rigid core products typically offer:

• Better dimensional stability
• Enhanced dent resistance from heavy furniture
• Improved performance over subfloor imperfections
• Greater stability in temperature fluctuations

For most installations, I recommend rigid core products unless budget constraints are significant. The performance advantages justify the modest price increase, particularly in areas with subfloor challenges or heavy furniture.

When comparing Style Selections to other brands, be aware that thickness specifications vary widely across the industry. Some manufacturers include attached underlayment in their total thickness measurements, while others specify plank-only thickness. Always clarify exactly what the stated measurements include when making comparisons.

The Review Landscape: What Are Others Saying?

Before investing in any flooring, investigating real-world experiences from other homeowners provides valuable insights. Style Selections vinyl plank has generated substantial online feedback across various platforms.

Where to Find Reliable Reviews

The most comprehensive sources for Style Selections reviews include:

1. Lowe’s website: Product-specific reviews from verified purchasers, often including installation experiences and long-term performance
2. Flooring forums: Sites like FloorTalk and Houzz where dedicated discussion threads cover Style Selections products
3. Social media groups: Facebook and Reddit communities focused on home renovation often contain detailed discussions and photos
4. YouTube: Several DIYers have documented their Style Selections installations and provided updates months or years later

In analyzing hundreds of reviews across these platforms, some consistent themes emerge:

Positive Feedback Patterns

1. Value proposition: Many reviewers cite the favorable quality-to-price ratio compared to premium brands
2. DIY-friendliness: First-time installers frequently report successful installations with minimal specialized tools
3. Appearance: Realistic wood visuals receive consistent praise, particularly in mid-range and premium lines
4. Water resistance: Performance in bathrooms, kitchens, and basements earns high marks from most users
5. Durability in normal conditions: Standard household use typically shows good wear resistance

One particularly telling review from a flooring contractor on a professional forum noted: “For the price point, Style Selections delivers better-than-expected performance. I recommend it to clients with realistic expectations and budget constraints.”

Common Criticisms

1. Consistency issues: Some reviewers report variation between boxes of the same product
2. Limited commercial viability: Heavy commercial environments reveal wear limitations more quickly than residential settings
3. Denting under heavy furniture: Static loads can cause permanent impressions without proper protection
4. Installation learning curve: First-time DIYers occasionally struggle with complex cutting requirements
5. Limited high-end options: Those seeking premium specifications may find the selection restricted compared to specialty brands

My personal experience aligns with the majority of positive reviews. The Style Selections products I’ve installed have delivered performance consistent with their price point—not matching the absolute premium brands but offering excellent value for typical household use.

When evaluating reviews, I recommend:

• Focusing on reviewers with similar household conditions (pets, children, traffic levels)
• Paying attention to the specific product line being reviewed (specifications vary significantly)
• Looking for long-term reviews (1+ years of use) rather than immediate post-installation impressions
• Considering the reviewer’s expectations and comparative context

This research approach helped me select appropriate Style Selections products for different areas of my home based on realistic performance expectations.

Brand Comparisons: How Does Style Selections Stack Up?

The vinyl plank flooring market features dozens of brands across various price points. Understanding how Style Selections compares to competitors helps place it in proper context.

Entry-Level Comparison

Compared to other budget-friendly options like Home Decorators Collection (Home Depot) and TrafficMaster:

• Pricing: Generally similar, with products ranging from $1.50-$3.00 per square foot
• Selection: Style Selections typically offers more design options than most entry-level competitors
• Specifications: Comparable wear layer thicknesses and construction methods
• Warranty: Similar limited residential warranties, generally 15-25 years
• Performance: Roughly equivalent durability and water resistance in most testing

In this category, Style Selections is competitive but not dramatically differentiated from similar house brands. The primary advantage is often the convenience of Lowe’s retail network and customer service.

Mid-Range Comparison

Against mainstream brands like Armstrong, Mohawk, and LifeProof:

• Pricing: Style Selections is typically 10-30% less expensive
• Selection: Fewer specialty options and premium features
• Specifications: Similar basic construction but often with thinner wear layers
• Warranty: Generally shorter protection periods or more limitations
• Performance: Good everyday durability but may show wear earlier in high-stress applications

This middle category is where Style Selections’ value proposition is strongest. While not matching all the specifications of dedicated flooring brands, it delivers comparable daily performance at noticeably lower prices for most household applications.

Premium Comparison

Compared to luxury vinyl plank brands like COREtec, Karndean, and Shaw:

• Pricing: Style Selections is substantially less expensive (often 40-60% lower)
• Selection: Fewer cutting-edge designs and specialized features
• Specifications: Generally thinner wear layers and less advanced construction
• Warranty: Less comprehensive coverage with more exclusions
• Performance: Noticeable differences in durability, dent resistance, and long-term appearance retention

Style Selections doesn’t truly compete in the premium category. Households requiring commercial-grade durability or seeking the absolute latest in vinyl plank technology will find meaningful advantages in premium brands—at corresponding price increases.

The Value Equation

Based on my installations and research, Style Selections positions itself as a “good enough” option rather than a “best available” product. This approach serves most residential needs effectively while offering significant cost savings.

For context, I installed Style Selections in most of my home but chose a premium brand (COREtec) for our sunroom, which experiences extreme temperature fluctuations and intense UV exposure. The premium product has indeed performed better in those challenging conditions—but at more than double the cost per square foot.

For standard living spaces without extraordinary requirements, Style Selections delivers approximately 80-90% of premium brand performance at 40-60% of the cost—a value equation that makes sense for many homeowners.

Pet-Friendly Flooring: Standing Up to Furry Friends

For many homeowners, pet compatibility is a non-negotiable flooring requirement. Dogs and cats present unique challenges with claws, accidents, and activity levels. How does Style Selections vinyl plank perform in pet households?

As a dog and cat owner, I’ve found that Style Selections vinyl plank is genuinely pet-friendly flooring that balances practical performance with budget considerations.

Scratch Resistance

Pet claws are a primary concern for any flooring. Style Selections products with 12 mil or higher wear layers offer good resistance to normal pet traffic. In our home:

• Regular dog walking shows minimal visible effects after three years
• Cat claws have created occasional fine scratches visible only under specific lighting
• Running and play activities have not caused significant surface damage

For maximum scratch protection, I recommend:

1. Selecting products with the thickest available wear layer (preferably 12-20 mil)
2. Choosing styles with textured surfaces and varied color patterns that help hide minor scratches
3. Maintaining pet nail trimming routines
4. Using area rugs in high-activity zones

Water and Accident Resistance

The waterproof nature of Style Selections rigid core products provides excellent protection against pet accidents and water bowl spills. Unlike hardwood or laminate, which can be permanently damaged by urine or standing water, properly installed waterproof vinyl plank:

• Prevents liquid penetration to subfloors
• Resists staining from pet accidents when promptly cleaned
• Allows for disinfecting without damaging the flooring
• Handles water bowl spills without warping or swelling

This water resistance has proven invaluable in our home, particularly during puppy training periods and with an elderly cat prone to occasional accidents.

Comfort and Traction

The surface characteristics of vinyl plank provide advantages for pets:

• Warmer surface than tile or stone for pet comfort
• More traction than highly polished surfaces, reducing slip risks for older pets
• Quieter than hardwood when pets run or play
• Softer impact surface for joint comfort in aging pets

Our 12-year-old dog noticeably prefers the vinyl plank to our previous ceramic tile, especially during winter months when the temperature difference becomes apparent.

Maintenance With Pets

Pet-specific maintenance considerations include:

1. Prompt cleaning of accidents: While vinyl is resistant to damage, urine can potentially seep between planks if left standing
2. Regular sweeping/vacuuming: Pet hair tends to accumulate along edges and in textured areas
3. Occasional deep cleaning: Enzymatic cleaners designed for pet odors work well on vinyl surfaces
4. Entrance mats: Placing mats at doors helps reduce tracked dirt and debris from outdoor adventures

Overall, Style Selections vinyl plank strikes an effective balance for pet owners—offering good resistance to common pet-related wear without the premium price of specialized pet-focused flooring options.

Damage Control: Removing and Replacing Problem Planks

Even with careful selection and installation, circumstances sometimes require replacing damaged vinyl planks. Perhaps a heavy object was dropped, creating a deep gouge, or a persistent stain refuses to come clean. The modular nature of Style Selections vinyl plank allows for targeted repairs without replacing the entire floor.

The replacement process varies depending on your installation method:

For Floating Click-Lock Installations

Replacing a damaged plank in the middle of a floating floor requires careful work:

1. Identify and prepare: Mark the damaged plank and have an exact replacement ready.
2. Create access: Using a circular saw set to the exact plank thickness, cut through the damaged plank lengthwise down the center, leaving about an inch uncut at each end.
3. Remove the damaged plank: Carefully pry up the cut section, then work outward to remove the edge pieces without damaging surrounding planks.
4. Prepare the replacement: Modify the replacement plank by removing the bottom portion of the locking mechanism on all sides.
5. Apply adhesive: Place a thin bead of vinyl flooring adhesive on the exposed subfloor.
6. Install the replacement: Slide the prepared replacement plank into position, press firmly, and clean any excess adhesive immediately.
7. Weight the repair: Place weight on the replacement plank until the adhesive cures (typically 24 hours).

I’ve used this method once to replace a plank damaged by a dropped cast iron pan. While not quite as secure as the original installation, the repair has remained stable for over a year with no noticeable movement or separation.

For Glue-Down Installations

Adhesive installations allow for a different approach:

1. Heat the damaged plank: Using a heat gun or hair dryer, warm the plank to soften the adhesive.
2. Remove carefully: Using a putty knife or similar tool, pry up the damaged plank while continuing to apply heat as needed.
3. Clean the subfloor: Remove all adhesive residue from the exposed subfloor area.
4. Apply new adhesive: Spread fresh vinyl flooring adhesive using the appropriate trowel.
5. Install replacement: Place the new plank and roll with a hand roller to ensure proper adhesion.
6. Clean and finish: Remove any adhesive squeeze-out and weight the area until cured.

This method typically results in a more secure repair since the entire plank is freshly adhered to the subfloor.

Important Considerations

Several factors affect replacement success:

1. Matching material: Ideally, use planks from your original purchase lot for exact color matching. This is why purchasing 5-10% extra initially is highly recommended.
2. Environmental conditions: Acclimate the replacement plank to room temperature for at least 24 hours before installation.
3. Surrounding stability: Ensure surrounding planks are secure before attempting replacement.
4. Expansion requirements: Maintain proper expansion spacing around the perimeter of the room.

For extensive damage affecting multiple planks, professional assistance may be warranted. However, isolated plank replacement is generally within the capabilities of homeowners with basic DIY skills and appropriate tools.

The replaceability of individual planks represents a significant advantage over sheet vinyl or glued hardwood flooring, where damage often necessitates much larger section replacement or refinishing.

Conclusion: The Final Verdict on Style Selections Vinyl Plank

After living with Style Selections vinyl plank flooring across multiple rooms for several years, my assessment comes down to this: Style Selections vinyl plank flooring delivers remarkable value for homeowners seeking attractive, practical flooring solutions without premium pricing.

Like any product, it involves tradeoffs. It won’t match the generational longevity of solid hardwood or the ultimate durability of porcelain tile. Yet for many households—including busy families with children and pets—it strikes an optimal balance between appearance, performance, and cost.

The strongest arguments in its favor include:

• Convincing wood-look aesthetics at fraction of hardwood costs
• Genuine DIY-friendly installation requiring minimal specialized tools
• Waterproof options suitable for bathrooms, kitchens, and basements
• Simple maintenance routines with no special cleaners or treatments
• Reasonable durability against everyday household challenges

Its limitations primarily center on:

• Variable quality between product lines requiring careful selection
• Less prestige than natural materials like hardwood or stone
• Limited refinishing options when wear eventually occurs
• Potential for denting under heavy static loads

For homeowners approaching flooring decisions with realistic expectations and practical budgets, Style Selections offers a compelling proposition. It won’t be the last floor you’ll ever install, but it provides years of attractive service at a price point that respects financial realities.

My recommendation? Invest in the mid-to-upper range Style Selections products with 12-20 mil wear layers and rigid core construction. These options deliver the best balance of performance and value, avoiding both the limitations of the most basic lines and the diminishing returns of premium-priced alternatives.

Whether you’re renovating a forever home or updating a rental property, Style Selections vinyl plank deserves serious consideration as a practical flooring solution that doesn’t compromise on appearance. Like many home improvement decisions, the wisest choice often isn’t at either extreme of the market but in that thoughtful middle ground where value truly resides.